H heath Member Joined Jan 10, 2003 Messages 35 Gender Male HSC 2003 Oct 13, 2003 #1 our teacher showed us this reallly really long method of proving the reflection property of the ellipse and hyperbola. i was wondering if there was an easy, preferably, quick method. ???
our teacher showed us this reallly really long method of proving the reflection property of the ellipse and hyperbola. i was wondering if there was an easy, preferably, quick method. ???
Affinity Active Member Joined Jun 9, 2003 Messages 2,062 Location Oslo Gender Undisclosed HSC 2003 Oct 13, 2003 #2 method 1 gradient bash: find gradients of teh two lines from focii to the point find gradient of ellipse at the point use the tan(@) =| (m1 - m2)/1 + m1m2 | formula method 2 'smart' way: prove SP + SP' = 2a for any point P on teh ellipse show that the sum of distances SQ + QS' where Q is any point on the tangent l at P is minimized when Q is P. let R be the reflection of S about l the PR = PS and show that S'PR is a straight line use geometry to deduce the angles are equal
method 1 gradient bash: find gradients of teh two lines from focii to the point find gradient of ellipse at the point use the tan(@) =| (m1 - m2)/1 + m1m2 | formula method 2 'smart' way: prove SP + SP' = 2a for any point P on teh ellipse show that the sum of distances SQ + QS' where Q is any point on the tangent l at P is minimized when Q is P. let R be the reflection of S about l the PR = PS and show that S'PR is a straight line use geometry to deduce the angles are equal
F felix_js lost Joined Oct 14, 2002 Messages 341 Gender Undisclosed HSC N/A Oct 13, 2003 #3 i remember seeing a way to do it with circles, can't remember it off the top of my head but im sure it was from the arnold book
i remember seeing a way to do it with circles, can't remember it off the top of my head but im sure it was from the arnold book