I take an idea of a story and use it for my story? Ok I don't mean same story, characters, themes, etc., I mean like, e.g., if I used a hot vampire and a girl in my story which is similar to Twilight (sorry, easiest e.g. I can think of). But the characters are different. So is it plagiarism if I sort of take the general idea?
Is it plagiarism if...? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter 2KL4SKL
- Start date
No, I shouldn't think so, but do you have any idea just how much this idea has been done? Well, in case you don't, it's been tragically done to death. I personally wouldn't recommend using vampires for your short story in the fear that it'll end up sounding like a Twilight fanfic. And quite frankly, basing anything of Twilight is a bad move. It's not the book has any themes or literary value. These days, people immediately associate vampires with Twilight and Twilight alone, which means that if you use them for your story chances are one of the markers are going to go, "Oh, GREAT, a Twilight fan....." Which is not what you want. Especially if the story sounds too close to Twilight anyway. The book is generic enough as it is: lonely city girl moves to hick town where she becomes amazingly popular but she just doesn't!fit!in! until she meets a mysterious man with whom she instantly connects with...
cassieagill
Member
no, its not plagarism
T
Take_It_Away
Guest
Plagiarism is using the ideas of others as if they were your own.
HSC : All My Own Work :: Plagiarism
HSC : All My Own Work :: Plagiarism
imsopostmodern
cool as a kuhncumber
it's not plagarism, but you might miss out on gaining marks for originality
Aerath
Retired
- Joined
- May 10, 2007
- Messages
- 10,169
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- N/A
OK - so that means every student is going to fail HSC English. As if anyone can think of an idea that has never been used before. Ever.
Last edited:
Kiim2507
Member
I had to do a uni assignment on plagiarism and that isn't plagiarism. If it were then everyone in the world would be plagiarising because there are no more original ideas.
I would highly recomend not writing a story about vampires though...everyone knows about Twilight so it isn't very original and you will be marked down.
I would highly recomend not writing a story about vampires though...everyone knows about Twilight so it isn't very original and you will be marked down.
T
Take_It_Away
Guest
From the 2007 HSC Notes From The Marking Centre for Paper 1 Section II:
(http://www.boardofstudies.nsw.edu.au...nced-notes.pdf)
"Some candidates were found to have reproduced, without acknowledgement, a substantial amount of sourced work, borrowing storyline, structure and/or language. These responses were regarded as limited in their appropriateness and received marks only for the parts of the response that were original. Candidates are reminded that responses must satisfy the requirements of the BOS ‘All Your Own Work’ policy."
rowdyroddy
Member
how would hsc markest know its plagiarism, like do they google each story or something
Absolutezero
real human bean
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2007
- Messages
- 15,077
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- N/A
^^They wouldn't know, you could probably get away with stealing an entire story if it's unknown enough. But the risks are too high...
The idea of the Ext 2 Project is to showcase your creativity. Using someone else's creativity as a basis for your story really does not fulfil the essence of the course. Certainly, you could use it to influence your new take, but I would make sure that it is new, fresh and VERY different.
rowdyroddy
Member
so fuck ext 2 then aye...