yeah when you are studying something like the dark knight its hard to avoid the temptation of wanting to get creative and write something of your ownn!!
What's your critical response about? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter grk_styl
- Start date
claudz3
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2008
- Messages
- 7
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2009
Woah, so, I'm only about 2,000 words into my response and I'm going insane, I keep feeling the need to cite/footnote everything. I haven't even starting exploring the texts that gave me an initial idea though. I'm stressing that i'm COMPLETELY off track...
If anyone wants to read what's done as of 4.30pm 7/2/09 follow this link: Download: ThesisWord.doc
Tell me what you think :]
If anyone wants to read what's done as of 4.30pm 7/2/09 follow this link: Download: ThesisWord.doc
Tell me what you think :]
Hi ! I recently decided to do a critical response, so let me know what you think..
At the moment I am thinking of exploring the effects of pop-culture and values upon post-war literature from the generations of Builders to Generation Y (ie including builders, baby boomers, gen x, gen y and how these generations and their influences affected the writing of the periods) but am not sure if this is something that would be recieved well, if its too uncreative or just too boring, which it seems to be after looking at everyone elses!
Please give feedback!
Claudz3, I'm impressed by your subject choice, and how interesting it is. I feel like going off and researching cannabalism now, just for interest (which I suppose re-iterates your thesis.) Well-written also, but I see what you mean about wandering off. It seems to present more of a history of cannabalism, rather than a literary analysis of it, so maybe you could try focus more on specific texts regarding cannabalism, like you mentioned in an earlier post, but obviously you havent finished yet so maybe thts what your planning. I liked what you did with Wrong Turn, but i would have been more interested if you expanded upon it a little more, included more textual references etc. Just because, looking at showcase, the ones with the detailed literary analysis' seemed to get good marks. Although you said you haven't gone it to them yet, so maybe that's why i feel like it's missing the textual analysis.
But over-all, if i was a marker i'd be interested and good writing =)
Hope i've been a little bit of help
At the moment I am thinking of exploring the effects of pop-culture and values upon post-war literature from the generations of Builders to Generation Y (ie including builders, baby boomers, gen x, gen y and how these generations and their influences affected the writing of the periods) but am not sure if this is something that would be recieved well, if its too uncreative or just too boring, which it seems to be after looking at everyone elses!
Please give feedback!
Claudz3, I'm impressed by your subject choice, and how interesting it is. I feel like going off and researching cannabalism now, just for interest (which I suppose re-iterates your thesis.) Well-written also, but I see what you mean about wandering off. It seems to present more of a history of cannabalism, rather than a literary analysis of it, so maybe you could try focus more on specific texts regarding cannabalism, like you mentioned in an earlier post, but obviously you havent finished yet so maybe thts what your planning. I liked what you did with Wrong Turn, but i would have been more interested if you expanded upon it a little more, included more textual references etc. Just because, looking at showcase, the ones with the detailed literary analysis' seemed to get good marks. Although you said you haven't gone it to them yet, so maybe that's why i feel like it's missing the textual analysis.
But over-all, if i was a marker i'd be interested and good writing =)
Hope i've been a little bit of help
Dog from Oz
New Member
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2009
- Messages
- 8
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2009
I am so far behind compared to you all. I need more time!!!
My major work is based on my Prelim Ext I stuff...Supernatural fiction.
Basically, I'm discussing the effects of social context on the portrayal of women in this genre.
So...Research consists of watching Buffy. Which I haven't done yet...
I'm the ONLY ONE in my Ext II class who is doing a crit resp...Makes it hard to talk about things...
Basically, I'm discussing the effects of social context on the portrayal of women in this genre.
So...Research consists of watching Buffy. Which I haven't done yet...
I'm the ONLY ONE in my Ext II class who is doing a crit resp...Makes it hard to talk about things...
Coolmeister
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2008
- Messages
- 4
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2009
I'm doing a comparative study of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series and CS Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia.
Going to look at how these texts differently represent ideas relating to religion, love & friendship, justice, etc., and what this says about changes to society and culture over the past 50 or so years.
I'm probably going to need to refine the topic a little...
Going to look at how these texts differently represent ideas relating to religion, love & friendship, justice, etc., and what this says about changes to society and culture over the past 50 or so years.
I'm probably going to need to refine the topic a little...
claudz3
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2008
- Messages
- 7
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2009
Yeah, I think i'm the only one doing a CA in my ExII class too.
I've just got more into the textual analysis part of my thesis, focusing on Hannibal Lecter and the power that a cannibal feels over his 'victim' and the fact that they're playing God, or consider themselves as a god-like figure.
"Tell me, Will. Did you enjoy it? Your first murder? Of course you did. And why shouldn't it feel good? It does to God. Why only last week in Texas, he dropped a church roof on the heads of 34 of his worshippers, just as they were grovelling for him. He wouldn't begrudge you for one Journalist." - Hannibal Lecter
I've just got more into the textual analysis part of my thesis, focusing on Hannibal Lecter and the power that a cannibal feels over his 'victim' and the fact that they're playing God, or consider themselves as a god-like figure.
"Tell me, Will. Did you enjoy it? Your first murder? Of course you did. And why shouldn't it feel good? It does to God. Why only last week in Texas, he dropped a church roof on the heads of 34 of his worshippers, just as they were grovelling for him. He wouldn't begrudge you for one Journalist." - Hannibal Lecter
I'm doing an analysis of the psychological thriller genre and how the themes are shaped by the character and setting in particular text. This then leads onto the idea of mental illness and its representation in the genre and the overriding philosophical explorations undertaken by the texts.
I'm using Room One Nineteen, The Killer Inside Me, Therapy, Mr Brooks, The Silence of the Lambs, Vertigo and Salad Fingers as specific texts that i'll reference.
And its so late in the year and i've hardly started... joy
I'm using Room One Nineteen, The Killer Inside Me, Therapy, Mr Brooks, The Silence of the Lambs, Vertigo and Salad Fingers as specific texts that i'll reference.
And its so late in the year and i've hardly started... joy
Tristine.Jane
New Member
- Joined
- Oct 24, 2008
- Messages
- 2
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2009
I'm very stuck, It's term 2 and I really don't have anything solid written at all. Is anyone else having the same problem?
Mine is on the representation of Solipsism in popular culture and it's various representations. ie. whether it's supported, questioned etc.... Taking a new historicist approach in some parts =)
That's my general thing anyway. I could explain more... but no one really understands it, I guess that leaves me a good 750 words or two to explain and such.... But yes. STUCK. I'm lost.
Mine is on the representation of Solipsism in popular culture and it's various representations. ie. whether it's supported, questioned etc.... Taking a new historicist approach in some parts =)
That's my general thing anyway. I could explain more... but no one really understands it, I guess that leaves me a good 750 words or two to explain and such.... But yes. STUCK. I'm lost.
CountVonChocula
Banned
- Joined
- Mar 20, 2009
- Messages
- 383
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2012
i'm abit stuck
mines mostly about schoolies and pickin up chicks in my car
but its really deep and metaphorical and thoughtful
but im in a rut and cant get out
help!
mines mostly about schoolies and pickin up chicks in my car
but its really deep and metaphorical and thoughtful
but im in a rut and cant get out
help!
Deer
Premium Member
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2008
- Messages
- 700
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2010
So, I'll start the ball rolling for EEII 2010!
Is anyone starting to think about critical response topics for next year? I know, it's a little early.
I'm thinking of doing one, even though my teacher is trying to talk me out of it due to the high amount of research... But I don't see that as a chore.
I'll see how it goes though, I might turn to short story if I'm staring at a blank page for much longer.. Ha. Naw, I have some ideas. It's been great reading though them on this thread! Seems like the most popular choice is feminism? I think I'll do something from a literary movement like out of Victorianism..... Hmm. Cogs'a spinnin'.
Is anyone starting to think about critical response topics for next year? I know, it's a little early.
I'm thinking of doing one, even though my teacher is trying to talk me out of it due to the high amount of research... But I don't see that as a chore.
I'll see how it goes though, I might turn to short story if I'm staring at a blank page for much longer.. Ha. Naw, I have some ideas. It's been great reading though them on this thread! Seems like the most popular choice is feminism? I think I'll do something from a literary movement like out of Victorianism..... Hmm. Cogs'a spinnin'.
ashie0
world
I still haven't decided between a speech or a critical response, i'm even less sure of the focus of my MW. Oh my...
Deer
Premium Member
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2008
- Messages
- 700
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2010
Do critical!
Then we can add each other on msn and winge to each other about our lack of motivation and our regrets about not choosing a short story XDD
Naw, I don't know, it's your choice.
I don't know my direction either, really. I wish I was more well-read.. I've borrowed some books on philosophy&literature, and I've been reading through them thinking, OH, what an interesting topic! But I haven't actually read any of the novels they're referring to...
Lol Deer, count me in. I'm opting for a critical response, too. At this moment in time anyway, it could change, but I doubt it.
What are some of the ideas you have?
I'm considering taking on a psychoanalytical approach to my chosen texts, which I haven't entirely reached a decision on yet. I want to look at one of Carl Jung's theories and explore the prevalence of that and question it's relevance in literature across contexts. It's related to the inherent 'darkness' within all individuals and the innate desire to succumb to that or the denial of it altogether. So, kind of looking at the human condition and the nature of individuals as morally ambiguous - which also lends hand to some principles of postmodernism.
What are some of the ideas you have?
I'm considering taking on a psychoanalytical approach to my chosen texts, which I haven't entirely reached a decision on yet. I want to look at one of Carl Jung's theories and explore the prevalence of that and question it's relevance in literature across contexts. It's related to the inherent 'darkness' within all individuals and the innate desire to succumb to that or the denial of it altogether. So, kind of looking at the human condition and the nature of individuals as morally ambiguous - which also lends hand to some principles of postmodernism.
Deer
Premium Member
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2008
- Messages
- 700
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2010
Ooh, that sounds great!! Be warned though that looking into that type of thing when you're going through a very stressful period can be pretty intense. In saying that though, (ha) I was going to do something very similar actually, look at the influence of Nietzsche's philosophy (nihilism) on literature and how it has manifested in different forms... Also possibly something on kafka or sartre and existentialism...
I had another idea of exploring the aestheticism movement and the transition between the victorian era and modernism focusing on the works of Oscar Wilde, and basically looking at what is art, art/morality, art/beauty/truth, etc.
But I'm actually having second thoughts at doing a critical now.
I went to the library and just did heaps of research but I got a bit ovewhelmed by it all.. Short story just looks so much easier. .. D:
Haha, thanks. Hmm, yeah, I've started to do some research and I've realised that I need to cover a lot of background in order to fully understand his theories. Still, it's so fascinating. Ah, Nietzsche! I came across him in my research too. Sounds really interesting =)
The first thing I thought when you mentioned art/beauty/truth was Keats, Ode on Melancholy, haha. That's bound to be pretty intriguing too, I really like your ideas.
Still, remember, short story requires a lot of research too in order to present deep and insightful understanding of your concept and the context of your story in some cases. But if you really don't feel up to doing a critical, short story has much more room for experimentation and allows you to explore slightly more freely than a critical. In my opinion, anyway. The satisfaction in completing one might be worth it though - think about the colossal amount of research and its payoff as a brilliant finished product ;p
As a side note, I can't believe BOS isn't blocked at our school. Almost everything is blocked.
The first thing I thought when you mentioned art/beauty/truth was Keats, Ode on Melancholy, haha. That's bound to be pretty intriguing too, I really like your ideas.
Still, remember, short story requires a lot of research too in order to present deep and insightful understanding of your concept and the context of your story in some cases. But if you really don't feel up to doing a critical, short story has much more room for experimentation and allows you to explore slightly more freely than a critical. In my opinion, anyway. The satisfaction in completing one might be worth it though - think about the colossal amount of research and its payoff as a brilliant finished product ;p
As a side note, I can't believe BOS isn't blocked at our school. Almost everything is blocked.
supercalamari
you've got the love
I have no regrets about not doing short stories... too much room for error and things can go totally haywire. Too subjective for me.
But I would love to talk to other 2010 kids who are doing critical... we have 30-ish kids in my year doing Ext II (10 or so dropped out already) but only three of us are doing critical. The bulk of them are doing short stories, one is doing poems and two are doing scripts.
We're an exciting bunch...