If you lunge at someone with a glass and there's a struggle I don't think it's that likely that your injuries would just so happen to be consistent with been glassed in the eye. You'd think your wrists and arms would be much more likely to be cut if the glass broke as you lunged at someone.So all you who think this guy is guilty, what are your opinions on the woman. Do you believe she started the fight and lunged at him with the glass? If you believe that much, i would think there is a possibility of unintended consequences of the glass breaking and injury following.