2011 HSC Prediction (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Dinamo
- Start date
Sculzyoner
Member
I'm thinking foreign policy as well. I just spent yesterday extracting quotes for it ... there's a severe lack of quotes in my class textbook.
anexasaved
Member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2009
- Messages
- 41
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2011
They had NEP last year. War communism is an option since it was last tested in 06 (as part of the Civil War)...i bloody hope its not on the power struggle, cause id struggle with a question about something that specific 
Usually they do a lenin and a stalin question dont they?
Usually they do a lenin and a stalin question dont they?
Skyzor
Member
Yup, it has always MOSTLY been like that.They had NEP last year. War communism is an option since it was last tested in 06 (as part of the Civil War)...i bloody hope its not on the power struggle, cause id struggle with a question about something that specific
Usually they do a lenin and a stalin question dont they?
But, what can happen is they might ask a question on the power struggle and another on Stalinism which leaves Lenin and Bolshevik consolidation of power totally out of it.
spaceflower
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2009
- Messages
- 23
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2011
I don't know if anyone is doing Germany for their national study BUT will they always ask a Wiemar Germany and a Nazi one? If they have 2 nazi germany ones I'm stuffed...
bigbirdbanana
Member
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2009
- Messages
- 83
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2011
Yeah, but since it's split up as 1918-1933 and 1933-1939 they can still ask you about the rise of the Nazi party, so read up on that!
I'm really hoping it's a generic Weimar question, eg 'Account for the successes and failures of the Weimar Republic'!
ArtemisOrthia
Member
Have to agree with both of you. They 'typically' do one and one from each section of the syllabus, but there's nothing saying that they must. Hope they be nice this year. n_n
A generic Weimar question would be such a gift! I hope you're right on the money! n_n
fakermaker
Member
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2011
- Messages
- 179
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2011
In both the CSSA and Independent exam, Germany's National study included the influence of Weimar's economic/Great depression to its failure or some shit.
I dont know if that means anything, but I'm very prepared for that question.
Versailles - Dawes - Ruhr and subsequent hyperinflation - young plan - Great Depression and subsequent transition of chancellors
So fucking easy.
I dont know if that means anything, but I'm very prepared for that question.
Versailles - Dawes - Ruhr and subsequent hyperinflation - young plan - Great Depression and subsequent transition of chancellors
So fucking easy.
Foreign policy is a favourite to be in the exam and my history teacher is really good at predicting exams.. she is usually right about them and she said that foreign policy is very possible..
They always have stalin as one option.. but i think it will have something to do with the bolshevik consolidation of power.. or stalin 5Y plan....
They always have stalin as one option.. but i think it will have something to do with the bolshevik consolidation of power.. or stalin 5Y plan....
zxreth
Member
- Joined
- Oct 11, 2009
- Messages
- 775
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2011
is this in relation to Germany or Russia? :S
ArtemisOrthia
Member
If you're right I'm going to go give my teacher the biggest hug ever. She had us do a practice response for that question during the last week of school. n_n
All the things they could ask, scare my socks off! D: D:
For Germany this year I reakon for Weimar they could asking something related to Versailles and WW1, like "To what extent was Germany's defeat in WW1 (or the treaty of Versailles) responsible for the fall of the Weimar government." Or they could ask "To what extent did the Great depression contribute to the downfall of Weimar democracy". I reakon for Nazi Germany they could ask something about social life maybe or racial policy.
It depends on the question, I reakon it would probably be "analyse the impact of Nazi racial policy on German society" In that case I would use R. Ovary's approach to structure the essay i.e.
Vilification – Use of propaganda to vilify the Jewish/other undesirables people, which would lead to their ostracization from German society
Discrimination – Enacting laws the deprive Jews/undesirables of their rights
Separation – Segregating Jews/undesirables from other Germans and moving them to concentration camps
In each paragraph I would analyse how they had an impact on those people. There are probably better approaches but thats what I would go with.
That's a nice approach, Overy always delivers the goods haha.
To add to the list, possibly an early years question? I don't think they've ever gone down that path, "how did the Weimar government deal with early threats", although it might be a little specific considering they usually span 1918-33 or 1933-39.
To add to the list, possibly an early years question? I don't think they've ever gone down that path, "how did the Weimar government deal with early threats", although it might be a little specific considering they usually span 1918-33 or 1933-39.
I think that would be too descriptive, because the question needs to get you to analyse.
Last edited: