MedVision ad

HSC and its Multiple Problems (1 Viewer)

helium

New Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
13
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
I initially sent this to the SMH but wasn't published. However, I would still like to share my thoughts on the HSC with you guys:
At this very moment, palms are perspiring, hearts are pounding and brains are going into overdrive ‎all over the state. Thirteen years of schooling and it has all come down to this: the HSC. ‎
As you casually browse this article, sipping on your cappuccino or perhaps sitting in traffic, around ‎‎70,000 Year 12 students are sitting in exam rooms across NSW, trying to regurgitate all they know ‎about ‘belonging’ within 2 hours. Perhaps, you are comforted by the thought that these students ‎have had ample mental preparation and imagine that they’ve been reassured, time and time again, ‎about how the ‘the HSC is just another test’. The thought of their sweating faces and cramping ‎heads no longer kindle waves of guilt and you guzzle down the remains of your coffee, without ‎another thought for these suffering teens.‎
Yet! Before you turn the page to peruse some more fascinating news, please, think back to the ‎past few weeks. Have you, late at night on the verge of sleep, heard a wild howl, half-human, half-‎animal, floating towards the night sky? Or perhaps, on a trip to the library, suddenly found yourself ‎face to face with a pale-faced, dark-eyed member of the living dead? These increasing incidences ‎of supernatural occurrences have been caused by the phenomenon euphemistically termed the ‎‎‘little quiz before schoolies’.‎
Despite the belief that the emotional and mental wellbeing of year 12 students has become ‎increasingly important to their respective schools, little can be done to truly prepare one for the ‎roller coaster experience. Parents would have had front-line experience, watching meltdowns, ‎passing tissues through the gap under the door and facing midnight study food cravings head on. ‎Despite the study guides churned out by the thousands and ‘relaxation sessions’ organised by ‎counsellors, any positive benefits from these programs are nullified by the cultural of competition ‎and the stress epidemic fostered by the Board of Studies. The increasing importance of rankings in ‎school assessments has become a key point of stress and sometimes, the direct cause of ‎breakdowns. Students feel that their ability is no longer determined by how well they perform, but ‎rather, how they perform in relation to others. For a student, an improvement in their abilities ‎suddenly appears insignificant, even down right useless, if their ranking remains a dismal number. ‎The feeling of ineptitude is haunting and hard-work is fruitless if a student cannot ‘beat’ their ‎classmates.‎
Throughout the year, the idea of collaborative study and assisting one’s peers is fearsome, after all, ‎isn’t helping classmates fraternising with the enemy? Then, suddenly, in the few weeks between ‎the end of school assessments and the start of the actual HSC, we are all encouraged to become ‎bosom friends again. In a blink, sharing notes and helping friends becomes, not only the actions of ‎a Good Samaritan, but will improve the performance of the entire cohort resulting in that glorified ‎occurrence known as ‘being scaled up’. The sudden shift in the politics of peer relationships the ‎few weeks leading up to the final exam is disconcerting, but definitely a much welcomed relief ‎from the terse, pseudo-‘Hunger Game’ atmosphere when internal rankings was at the forefront of ‎everyone’s mind.‎
Although displeasure was the primary sentiment among HSC students as they confront their final ‎exams, rebellion has been kept down by a mixture of extreme exhaustion and good sense. ‎Achieving a workable and effective examination system is difficult, although it is difficult to admit ‎this when one is caught up within the bureaucracy itself. Furthermore, the very nature of testing is ‎competition and for all out complaints about ‘being defined by a number’, how else are we going ‎to summon the motivation to work towards our dream course? Thus, think of our complaints about ‎the HSC as a final cry of rebellion from a group of teens about to be cast into the realm of ‎adulthood. We wish you a fine day and once this pop quiz is done, we’ll be joining you in the real ‎world.‎
 

SunnyScience

Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2011
Messages
706
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
I really like it - good job. :) Maybe a bit too much/too far on the whole 'supernatural' thing though...The part about ranking, however, is excellent.
 

tomp1612

Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2012
Messages
215
Location
Tatooine
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
this needs t be published, it is all true, too much stress on students for a damn number!!!!!
 

SpiralFlex

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2010
Messages
6,960
Gender
Female
HSC
N/A
With any education system there will always be problems.
 

forgot

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
62
Gender
Female
HSC
2011
Uni Grad
2015
so true... really aims on how pressure students suffer for an exam. its not the end of the world
 

EvansOne

Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2012
Messages
36
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
We should have an SAT-style exam; I quite like that system. You sit your SAT's in junior year (yr 11), and if you don't like what you get then you sit them again in senior year (yr 12). If you somehow do worse in year 12 then your year 11 mark counts. How good is that for preparation? If you screw up both then you can just pay the $51 fee and do the test again the next year. Oh, not to mention the test is broken up into Reading, Writing and Maths only, provided you don't select any extension exams. It's a one-off test that lasts 4 hours; you aren't ever told that it's the be-all and end-all of your schooling - heck, you can just take it again if you screw up. Further, it's ranked to be in similar difficulty to the HSC, even though it sounds much easier (the essays, for example, are all based on unseen texts for the most part).

I think a similar system with slight tweaks (more subjects, for example) could work very well.
 

mirinbrah1

Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2012
Messages
33
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
We should have an SAT-style exam; I quite like that system. You sit your SAT's in junior year (yr 11), and if you don't like what you get then you sit them again in senior year (yr 12). If you somehow do worse in year 12 then your year 11 mark counts. How good is that for preparation? If you screw up both then you can just pay the $51 fee and do the test again the next year. Oh, not to mention the test is broken up into Reading, Writing and Maths only, provided you don't select any extension exams. It's a one-off test that lasts 4 hours; you aren't ever told that it's the be-all and end-all of your schooling - heck, you can just take it again if you screw up. Further, it's ranked to be in similar difficulty to the HSC, even though it sounds much easier (the essays, for example, are all based on unseen texts for the most part).

I think a similar system with slight tweaks (more subjects, for example) could work very well.
But that sounds logical, no way will that happen.
 

nifkeh

Member
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
383
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
I initially sent this to the SMH but wasn't published. However, I would still like to share my thoughts on the HSC with you guys:
At this very moment, palms are perspiring, hearts are pounding and brains are going into overdrive ‎all over the state. Thirteen years of schooling and it has all come down to this: the HSC. ‎
As you casually browse this article, sipping on your cappuccino or perhaps sitting in traffic, around ‎‎70,000 Year 12 students are sitting in exam rooms across NSW, trying to regurgitate all they know ‎about ‘belonging’ within 2 hours. Perhaps, you are comforted by the thought that these students ‎have had ample mental preparation and imagine that they’ve been reassured, time and time again, ‎about how the ‘the HSC is just another test’. The thought of their sweating faces and cramping ‎heads no longer kindle waves of guilt and you guzzle down the remains of your coffee, without ‎another thought for these suffering teens.‎
Yet! Before you turn the page to peruse some more fascinating news, please, think back to the ‎past few weeks. Have you, late at night on the verge of sleep, heard a wild howl, half-human, half-‎animal, floating towards the night sky? Or perhaps, on a trip to the library, suddenly found yourself ‎face to face with a pale-faced, dark-eyed member of the living dead? These increasing incidences ‎of supernatural occurrences have been caused by the phenomenon euphemistically termed the ‎‎‘little quiz before schoolies’.‎
Despite the belief that the emotional and mental wellbeing of year 12 students has become ‎increasingly important to their respective schools, little can be done to truly prepare one for the ‎roller coaster experience. Parents would have had front-line experience, watching meltdowns, ‎passing tissues through the gap under the door and facing midnight study food cravings head on. ‎Despite the study guides churned out by the thousands and ‘relaxation sessions’ organised by ‎counsellors, any positive benefits from these programs are nullified by the cultural of competition ‎and the stress epidemic fostered by the Board of Studies. The increasing importance of rankings in ‎school assessments has become a key point of stress and sometimes, the direct cause of ‎breakdowns. Students feel that their ability is no longer determined by how well they perform, but ‎rather, how they perform in relation to others. For a student, an improvement in their abilities ‎suddenly appears insignificant, even down right useless, if their ranking remains a dismal number. ‎The feeling of ineptitude is haunting and hard-work is fruitless if a student cannot ‘beat’ their ‎classmates.‎
Throughout the year, the idea of collaborative study and assisting one’s peers is fearsome, after all, ‎isn’t helping classmates fraternising with the enemy? Then, suddenly, in the few weeks between ‎the end of school assessments and the start of the actual HSC, we are all encouraged to become ‎bosom friends again. In a blink, sharing notes and helping friends becomes, not only the actions of ‎a Good Samaritan, but will improve the performance of the entire cohort resulting in that glorified ‎occurrence known as ‘being scaled up’. The sudden shift in the politics of peer relationships the ‎few weeks leading up to the final exam is disconcerting, but definitely a much welcomed relief ‎from the terse, pseudo-‘Hunger Game’ atmosphere when internal rankings was at the forefront of ‎everyone’s mind.‎
Although displeasure was the primary sentiment among HSC students as they confront their final ‎exams, rebellion has been kept down by a mixture of extreme exhaustion and good sense. ‎Achieving a workable and effective examination system is difficult, although it is difficult to admit ‎this when one is caught up within the bureaucracy itself. Furthermore, the very nature of testing is ‎competition and for all out complaints about ‘being defined by a number’, how else are we going ‎to summon the motivation to work towards our dream course? Thus, think of our complaints about ‎the HSC as a final cry of rebellion from a group of teens about to be cast into the realm of ‎adulthood. We wish you a fine day and once this pop quiz is done, we’ll be joining you in the real ‎world.‎
you can send it to them as a letter to the editor or editorial - not as a newspaper article in full because it's really opinionated - newspaper articles cannot have bias or opinions but if it's a letter to the editor you can write from your own point of view, and it may be accepted that way. :)
 

Cheesecake_a

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
369
Gender
Female
HSC
2012
I agree with this article. I hate thought that is unlikely things will change much... I want to say we should do something about it, but heck, what will happen anyway?
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top