If a function is continuous and increasing then if x1 > x2 then f(x1) > f(x2) (draw a picture if this isn't obvious). In this case, it appears that a contradiction is occuring because 2 > -1 yet f(2) < f(-1). The answer is because the function isn't continuous at x = 0. Hence, it doesn't make sense to compare the points x = 2 and x = -1 to confirm that the function is increasing because they are on different branches of the hyperbola.