MedVision ad

Gwen Harwood (1 Viewer)

posterboy142

New Member
Joined
May 14, 2004
Messages
24
Location
northern beaches
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2004
Hi

I was wondering if a psychoanaltical reading can be done with 'Prize Giving" and also wat poem is recommended to do with "the violets"
 

vally

New Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2004
Messages
15
u cant apply psyhoanalysis to prize giving. even if u can, which im sure u could if u reaaally tried, they dont expect u to. thats what our teacher said. so leave it out for prize givin cos u cant do it. as for the violets, i don't know because i'm not going to study that one. i hate that poem. but i know it primarily focuses on the use of memory and the violets themselves symbolise memory
 

cro_angel

<3<3<3
Joined
Nov 7, 2003
Messages
3,309
Location
Somewhere over the rainbow
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
Umm you can see it psychologically in the sense that Sigmund Freud said that "Human behaviour is ultimately motivated by sexuality" [thats the only random related notes i could find on that and prize giving]
but yeh you dont need to apply every reading to every poem but you should still know something about all poems because they could specify one and say like "Refer to the glass jar and two other poems" or something like that..
just know at least two ways of reading each poem
 

rainonmay

floating around
Joined
Mar 19, 2004
Messages
212
Location
sum where...
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
then whats another reading that can be done of prize-giving apart from feminist...
 

kimmeh

Sleeping
Joined
Jul 5, 2003
Messages
4,501
Location
Stables, Paddocks, Pens, Kennels, Cages
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
^cro_angel just posted: Sigmund Freud said that "Human behaviour is ultimately motivated by sexuality" so thus you can apply a psychoanalytical reading to it. You might want to look up Jung and his archetypes. I beleive that the best archetype for this poem would be the anima/animus one
 

Simmey

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Messages
36
Location
Around
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
Sure you can!

You can apply readings to Prize giving.
I've got one of those module study books and it says that:

"A marxist reading of prize giving would be critical of the view of society presented in the poem and analyse the power relationships between the various characters and how these are influenced by various factors, such as gender, age, education and rank.
It is significant that the poem presents a distoted view of society, in that the school is clearly a middle class institution. The Head, as the leading representitive of the school, values pomp and ceremony, having gone to great lengths to create an atmosphere of importance, added to by the attendance of professor eisenbart 'an honoured guest'.

It is significant that the poem does engage in light - hearted ridicule of the speech-night tradition and the Head's illusions of superiority.

Prof Eisenbart is clearly a member of the privileged class. His academic superiority is evident through academic gowns. As a member of the upper-class he distinguished himself from the masses.

(It gets better here!)

It is significant that the girl is presented as an insubordinate member of the masses, inferior to the Prof in education, age, gender and yet presenting a challenge to him. This could be interpreted as symbolic of her challenging the middle-class, patriarchial beliefs and the values that both the prof and the school represent. Through the actions of the titian-haired girl, the prof is exposed to as a 'sage fool'. He and the element of society that he represents is ridiculed and trivialised"
___________________

you can also apply a femminist reading

"It is significant that the prof has been invited as an honoured guest to a 'GIRLs school speech night'. The suggestion is that his achievements as a successful MAN will "lend distinction...to the occaison"

In addition, the prof's disdain for the occasion, having rudely declined the intial invitation and the achievements of the young women who hands "He shook/indifferently" he sees them as a collective group rather than individuals.

*Interaction between the prof and the Headmistres is significant to a feminist readoing. The fact that he is "supurb in silk and fur' and she is dressed 'humbler in black' suggest that there is an imbalance in power between the genders.

* Notably the head fusses and fawns over the professor, she is presented as subservient to him

*Interation between eisenbart and the redhead girl. From the outset the relationship between them is a power struggle. The prof first notices her as she mocks and mimics him.
"One girl sat grimming at him, her hand bent,
under her chin in mockery of his own"
however as the girl accepts her award the girl established immediate power over the prof.

*The provocative connotations of the girls actions as she "hitched at her stocking" and "winked" prior to accepting the award are particularly significant. The implication that the girl gains power over the prof thru virtue of her sexuality.

*The prof's loss of power and autonomy as she draws "his stare with her to the piano" contributes to the construction of an image of a woman with power who should be feared by men. The titian-haired girl is ascribed with the qualities of a seductress, whist her musical talents and the achievement of the music award is marginalised.

thats about all its got. I know that its a bit ambiguous but oh well... its something in case it comes up!
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top