McLovin said:
a typo, well done at being pedantic though *thumbs up* simple spelling mistake attacks on forums got old a while ago.
McLovin said:
Expressive techniques is the way the art is created idiot! How can you have musical art without pitch, duration, texture , tone colour etc?!
Philosophy has little to do with music, it is practical art and is different to poetry. So the basic point is music depends on these 'technical' terms in order to function.
ok we'll start with a dictionary definition of music, not your wanky arbitrary standards of 'what REAL music is'
primary def: 1. an art of sound in time that expresses ideas and emotions in significant forms through the elements of rhythm, melody, harmony, and color.
now, what you are trying to get at is the encoding process, but if you want to make comments on 'it isnt real music' 'it isnt art' you're talking about the preception of it, you are talking about the decoding process, a world where your tech terms do not matter so much.
I think you should also note that pitch applies to the human voice, which differs ALOT in rap music.
philosophy has little to do with music? music is an art.
A is B. philosophy has alot to do with music and 'whether or not it is art'
it conveys emotions, depicts stories etc = IT IS ART
IT IS MUSIC
think outside of the stupid little box you obviously think inside of. Or get a new box. At least something because your box must be the size of a fucking standard rubix cube.
now go home and watch that youtube video of a member of a HIP HOP band play hendrix and dylan and his guitar and SHUT THE FUCK UP
Js^-1 said:
assume your at University. So what, you don't attend lectures, classes or tutorials? I don't reply because I am actively learning, and you look down on me. Still, it's a nice way to point out the hypocrisy of your other arguments, that I am 'ignorant'. You think that by attempting to ridicule someone who is debating against you, you undermine their argument. It just makes you sound like an idiot.
maybe i don't have anything on thursdays???
are you at high school 24/7 now?
Yes I look down on you, I've been through that 'thats not real music' phase that you are going through, i now realise how stupid i was then, just like you are now.
so run along little kid.
