well id rather have someone that can do the job than rely on our strikers again. i mean apart from rooney, there is no other prolific striker in the sqaud, that can stay fully fit. saha is only a 4mth man, solksjaer can only do it in 15mins per game, smith isnt a goalscorer and never was, rossi is to simliar to rooney and unproven in epl. I mean, look at end of this season when we had to play rooney on his own, he isnt great in that position, and works flawlessly with saha. the problem is saha isnt fit all the time, so another version of him in anelka would be perfect, plus he is a proven goalscorer in the epl, fast which is wat fergie wants, and links up well within the counter attack which is how united play i mean imagine an attack of ronaldo, rooney, giggs(nani), and anelka charging up the field.
id rather have him than no striker coming in, and id rather not take huntelaar, seems like RVN version 2. the only other cheaper options could be darren bent, but id rather we stay clear of him. tevez will be expensive, etoo (would be perfect but way to pricey), torres again pricey, kinda limits our options.