• Congratulations to the Class of 2024 on your results!
    Let us know how you went here
    Got a question about your uni preferences? Ask us here

Search results

  1. Trebla

    Help with complex

    Since \alpha is a root then \alpha^2+\alpha+1=0 Which implies \alpha^n+\alpha^{n-1}+\alpha^{n-2}=0 Use the same argument for \beta and the result follows For the strong induction step use the property that T_{n+1}=-T_n-T_{n-1} and...
  2. Trebla

    Seriously - why the hell is English compulsory?

    This is not true. Moderating of internal school assessment marks is based on external HSC marks within a subject. It looks at each school's internal marks and adjusts them based on their performance in the external HSC exam for that subject. There is no comparison between subjects at all in how...
  3. Trebla

    How do state ranks work???

    Not sure where you got that from but this is definitely not true. If you look that the actual state ranks in previous years you see plenty of examples where students from lower ranked schools were placed above or tied with those from higher ranked schools
  4. Trebla

    Any copyright issues for uploading past Year 11 Prelim Maths Advaced + Extension 1 Papers for new syllabus?

    As long as it’s for educational purposes only and not for commercial sale then I think it should be okay.
  5. Trebla

    Binomial Theorem Questions

    See the yellow sticky which has the hyperlink and go to the relevant subject
  6. Trebla

    Complex roots questions

    For part a), let y = 1 + 1/z and the equation reduces to a roots of unity problem (but with one less solution as y cannot equal 1). Use some double angle manipulations when you return it in terms of z and you should get the answer.
  7. Trebla

    Nice proof

    The decomposition step is perfectly valid for integer values of x. The invalid step is the differentiation step because it is not recognising that the number of terms is also a variable.
  8. Trebla

    Nice proof

    The main flaw is that the number of terms is also a variable whereas the additivity of differentiation applies when the number of terms is fixed. A similar example is writing: x = 1+1+1+....+1 (x-times) Leading to the 1 = 0 fallacy. Another flaw is that this decomposition assumes x is an...
  9. Trebla

    Aligned mark question

    The scaled mark is the mark that goes into calculating your ATAR - done by UAC. The aligned mark is the mark you see on your HSC document - done by NESA. They are two independent ways to treat the same raw mark for different purposes.
  10. Trebla

    Difficult question which involves a geometric series

    If you write out Rn explicitly using the general terms of a GP you should notice that you can factorise rn. From that point the rest should follow.
  11. Trebla

    Correlation between Complex Locus and Circle Geometry (former harder 3u)

    Pretty much agree with this, especially the last sentence. Practicing old syllabus circle geometry questions only really helps in terms of sharpening general geometry reasoning skills (which you won’t use much of since the new syllabus has minimal geometry). It’s less relevant in helping with...
  12. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    There is no “chicken-egg” thing here. Aptitude (for problem solving in this context) by definition means an individual’s innate (not learnt) abilities or natural instincts - which is clearly separate from any abilities gained from practice. It is something you and I (and anyone naturally...
  13. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    So we both agree that a difficult integral can be solved either by: - calling upon prior experience; or - using problem solving skills to derive a solution from scratch How is that consistent with your primary assertion later on suggesting that having prior experience is the only way to be able...
  14. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    Maybe today it looks obvious that you are drawing from your personal experience but I am pointing out that a student could never have experienced that type of ‘tricky’ integral and still be able to independently construct the solution from scratch - using only logical deduction and basic IBP...
  15. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    My point was not about the application of a memorised/prescriptive strategy, but rather the construction of a strategy from scratch by analysing an unfamiliar problem and applying deductive reasoning (e.g. to arrive at the best choice of what to differentiate/integrate). Maybe you were directly...
  16. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    Rote learning every single method out there is one way to be successful at integration. You can be good at integration without rote learning, especially if you are good at recognising patterns and have good foresight on what an approach will lead to. Classic example is integrating say x3ex2...
  17. Trebla

    Rote learning in Maths

    I don’t see much difference in trying to figure out a difficult integral and figuring out a difficult Olympiad problem in terms of skills drawn upon. Both require problem solving skills (i.e. the skill of applying your knowledge) which is completely separate to the method of acquisition of said...
  18. Trebla

    Selective schools debate

    The performance of a handful of people in an Olympiad is not necessarily representative of the population’s average.
  19. Trebla

    Selective schools debate

    Not sure what you mean by that? Either way, it’s hardly relevant because they’re counted in the cohort regardless and will influence the moderating of internal marks. That table is evidence that just because you’re in a top tier selective school doesn’t mean you’re guaranteed to get a high...
  20. Trebla

    Selective schools debate

    Not Ruse, but here is the ATAR distribution for Sydney Boys http://www.sydneyboyshigh.com/publications/document-library/doc_view/7845-atar-breakdown-2001-2018 Out of 207 students in 2018, 52 (roughly 25%) got ATARs below 90 and 25 (roughly 12%) got ATARs in the 70s or less. So basically, if...
Top