Board of Studies reveals 2004 raw marks (3 Viewers)

[wrong_turn]

but that would mean that a statute would have had to be made since the stature overides the precedent ?? what the hell?? so that means i wont be able to get my raw marks back? stupid government!

 

[melsc]

but that would mean that a statute would have had to be made since the stature overides the precedent ?? what the hell?? so that means i wont be able to get my raw marks back? stupid government!

Yepzies remember wrong turn wat did you learn in legal studies when there is a clash between common and statute law, statute law prevails, also that the government at anytime can make a law that overrides a precedent as long as its not unconstitutional

 

[wrong_turn]

Yepzies remember wrong turn wat did you learn in legal studies when there is a clash between common and statute law, statute law prevails, also that the government at anytime can make a law that overrides a precedent as long as its not unconstitutional

melsc i was just stating my disbelief or merely questioning the illogical truth that it seems i just cant believe that the parliament would amend or create an act for this?! if they have they are shonks!!

 

[melsc]

melsc i was just stating my disbelief or merely questioning the illogical truth that it seems i just cant believe that the parliament would amend or create an act for this?! if they have they are shonks!!

They have too much time on their hands ...lol u know me I jump at any excuse to spout legal stuff

 

[Lazarus]

There is no statute or legislation that prevents you gaining access to your own marks.

There isn't even a common law decision yet - nothing has been decided by the courts.

All that has happened is that the Board has made an administrative decision which has not yet been challenged.

 

[melsc]

There is no statute or legislation that prevents you gaining access to your own marks.

There isn't even a common law decision yet - nothing has been decided by the courts.

All that has happened is that the Board has made an administrative decision which has not yet been challenged.

Could someone take it to the AAT if they really wanted?

 

[Lazarus]

The appropriate action would be to seek a review of the decision in the NSW ADT (the State equivalent of the Cwlth AAT).

So, yes, it can be done, by someone with proper standing.

 

[Captain pi]

The appropriate action would be to seek a review of the decision in the NSW ADT (the State equivalent of the Cwlth AAT).

So, yes, it can be done, by someone with proper standing.

What, in this instance, would be involved in a review by the NSW ADT?

 

[SashatheMan]

HSC over for me, i dotn came any more how they scaled me. all i care now is for it to get Harder so others can suffer mahaha

 

[~ ReNcH ~]

HSC over for me, i dotn came any more how they scaled me. all i care now is for it to get Harder so others can suffer mahaha

I have to admit that that was one of the most random posts I have ever seen on BoS

 

[mattchan]

you know, do you get your 30 bucks back if your application is denied?

 

[Lazarus]

No.

But if you appeal, and the decision is overturned, you can have the appeal fee reimbursed.

 

[Danni07]

So, will we (the 2005ers) have the chance to fill out this form and request our raw marks? Is there any hope that we will receive them?

 

[Captain pi]

So, will we (the 2005ers) have the chance to fill out this form and request our raw marks? Is there any hope that we will receive them?

Any citizen has the right to make an application under the Freedom of Information Act.

As to the likelihood of disclosure, that is dependent on how far you intend to pursue it. In my immense legal knowledge ( ) and my dealings with the Board, I would say that it would be a dead set certainty that the Board would internally refuse the documents; however, if you took it to the Administrative Decisions Tribunal, I think it would be (almost) certain that the documents would be disclosed – but this means forking out the dough for legal costs etc. etc.

 

[Lazarus]

I agree with Captain pi.

The legal costs would (roughly) be:

$30 initial application fee (BOS)
$40 internal review fee (BOS)
$55 external review fee (ADT)

= $125

But once that was done, if successful, any student would be able to obtain their marks with just the initial fee of $30.

 

[Captain pi]

I agree with Captain pi.

The legal costs would (roughly) be:

$30 initial application fee (BOS)
$40 internal review fee (BOS)
$55 external review fee (ADT)

= $125

But once that was done, if successful, any student would be able to obtain their marks with just the initial fee of $30.

If someone requested all raw band cut-offs and made them public, no-one would really need to make an application as an accurate estimation (rounding would still cause problems) for the raw marks could be deduced from the cut-offs.

I wonder if all HSC students should employ someone to make such an application: $125/60000 = less than 0.3 c each.

 

[Lazarus]

There might be a few more costs incurred in a matter like that... raw band cut-offs are (or seem to be?) slightly more controversial, which means the Board would be more likely to appeal an adverse decision made by the Tribunal.

Though I suppose the actual cost of the appeal would fall to them. Mainly just additional costs in terms of time and preparation etc.

 

[Captain pi]

There might be a few more costs incurred in a matter like that... raw band cut-offs are (or seem to be?) slightly more controversial, which means the Board would be more likely to appeal an adverse decision made by the Tribunal.

Though I suppose the actual cost of the appeal would fall to them. Mainly just additional costs in terms of time and preparation etc.

[comment]I'll speak to you in November. [/comment]

 

[Lazarus]

Any citizen has the right to make an application under the Freedom of Information Act.

[comment]Very clever. [/comment]

 

[reggina_calcio]

Hi,

Im an 05er and was thinking about sending one in. Is it too ealry to do it now? Should I wait until Nov/Dec?

Also, should I use the form that was linked earlier in this thread? Has it been modified to give the 'ticks'...if so, do you think they (BOS) will recognise my application is from here (boredOS) and .'. not accept it due to the likeliehood of me putting my results up here...


Shouldnt I be studyig now?